Is permanent retraction of the foreskin as an alternative to circumcision valid in Islam?

There is no direct answer to this question in Islamic jurisprudence. Some scholars allow for permanent retraction of the foreskin as an alternative to circumcision, while others do not. There is no consensus among scholars on this issue, and ultimately it is up to the individual to decide whether or not to have it done.

Those who allow for permanent retraction of the foreskin argue that it fulfills the requirement of circumcision, which is to remove the foreskin. They also argue that it is less invasive and has fewer risks than circumcision.

Those who do not allow for permanent retraction of the foreskin argue that it is not a legitimate form of circumcision and that it does not fulfill the requirements of Islamic law. They also argue that it can lead to health problems, such as phimosis and paraphimosis.

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not to have permanent retraction of the foreskin is a personal one. If you are considering this procedure, it is important to talk to a qualified medical professional and to weigh the risks and benefits before making a decision.